Hello dear
Welcome to Margarita's Pizzeria II
Margarita's Pizzeria II, nestled in Chicago’s 346 E 75th St, is a true neighborhood gem serving fresh, flavorful pizza with a perfectly thin, toasted crust. Their sausage, green pepper, and spinach toppings create a satisfying blend, though the spinach can be a bit chunky. Beyond pizza, their hearty, meat-filled spaghetti impresses with rich, Bolognese-style sauce at an excellent value. The staff delivers friendly, precise service, enhancing the dining experience. Revisiting this spot feels like coming home—each bite bursts with authentic, well-crafted flavors that keep locals and newcomers returning. Margarita's Pizzeria II stands out for taste, quality, and community warmth.
Featured Choices
Taste what’s trending on the menu
Tacos
Turkey Burger
It Meatball
It Combo
About
Margarita's Pizzeria II
Margarita's Pizzeria II stands out as a true culinary gem in Chicago's vibrant 75th Street neighborhood. This eatery has quietly built a reputation for delivering fresh, flavorful pizzas that arrive right on time, matched by a warm and attentive staff that makes every visit enjoyable. The pizzas here strike a perfect balance with crisp, thin crusts that are toasted to perfection, offering a satisfying crunch with every bite.
One of the highlights is their individual-sized pizzas, like the 9-inch sausage, green pepper, and spinach option, which boasts well-layered flavors. While the spinach presentation might lean towards a more rustic, chunked style, it adds a unique texture that some diners may find nostalgic or comforting, reminiscent of classic Italian-American pizzerias. For those who enjoy hearty pasta, the spaghetti with its rich, meat-filled sauce is a standout, providing a taste and portion that is both affordable and deeply satisfying.
Returning customers consistently praise the consistency and authentic taste, underscoring the pizzeria’s long-standing presence and commitment to quality. The large sausage and cheese pizzas deliver bold, robust flavors that linger long after the meal, evoking a sense of nostalgia for loyal patrons and charm for newcomers alike.
Overall, Margarita's Pizzeria II offers more than just pizza—it serves genuine comfort food rooted in tradition with an inviting neighborhood vibe. Whether you're craving a perfectly baked pie or a flavorful plate of spaghetti, this spot promises an honest and hearty dining experience that truly honors its craft.
Stories & Reviews
Guestbook
“ Excellent pizza very fresh and right on time! I’m glad and happy I found this place. The staff was very nice and my order was precise(: thank you ”
“ Not sure how long this place been on 75th, but it's definitely a hidden pizza gem. I didn't order anything else. I had the 9in individual pizza with sausage,green pepper and spinach. All the flavors were perfect and the crust was thin and toasted perfectly. However the spinach was in chunks on my pizza and I didn't like that. It was giving canned spinach. Anyways I smashed and will be back. ”
“ Amazing I used to go to this place all the time when I lived over east, and when I lived over there the pizza was awesome still is when I moved in 2005 from over East I had to see if they were still there and they were, I had to go revisit and it was worth it I brought me a large sausage and cheese pizza and it was phenomenal, very pleased very happy great taste was off the chain! ”
“ Got spaghetti for the first time tonight. And it's amazing. Less than 5 bucks and the sauce is meat filled. Looks more like a Bolognese but its hearty. ”